Attention Boards: Your Two Favorite Menaces Have Combined: Airbnb and Pets!
Whether I am giving a presentation to hundreds of people, teaching a class to dozens of managers or meeting privately with a board of directors, the two issues that have come up without fail over the last few months are: Airbnb and Emotional Support Animals (ESAs) and other pet issues.
The questions I field on these topics usually sound like this:
“Our community is turning into a hotel. We have people coming and going at all hours and we have no idea who they are and, in addition to our security concerns, our recreational amenities are taking a beating.”
“We are a no pet community but we have people bringing in more dogs each year and claiming they are emotional support animals. What about the people who bought here specifically because they do not want to or cannot live in close contact with dogs?
As a result of having recently rescued a dog from our local Humane Society, I have been searching for ideas to keep her from tearing down the house during working hours when she is alone. Lo and behold I cam across a site which advertised itself as “Airbnb for Dogs”! Oy. For a fee you can drop off your pet at a sitter’s home but just imagine if that home happens to be inside a pet-restricted condominium or HOA? You get the best (or worst depending on one’s perspective) of both violations!
With regard to Airbnb, VRBO, HomeAway and other similar sites, the ability to control your owners’ engagement in this type of short-term rental activity depends largely on the provisions in your association’s governing documents. If you were hoping your local government would help regulate this activity you should know that Airbnb is making that much more difficult by pursuing legislation which would restrict or prohibit a local government’s ability to impact their business model which means your association is likely to be on its own when trying to regulate this behavior. Attempting to pursue each violation as a violation of your minimum leasing requirements can be both costly and laborious given that each renal lasts only mere days. In my opinion, it is more effective to amend your documents to make the listing of properties in your community on these sites the violation rather than focusing on the rental term.
“But how can we tell if we have properties in our community listed on these sites before the guests show up?” you might ask. Wherever there is a problem, a cottage industry designed to solve it cannot be far behind and the same is true here. There are now companies that exist which search these short-term rental sites each month to confirm whether or not there are units or homes in your community listed there. When those listings are found, your board can spring into action.
With regard to emotional support animal requests, I realize that you may question the truthfulness of many of these requests. You may even feel that the cards are very much stacked against a volunteer board of directors attempting to enforce reasonable pet restrictions. This does not mean that associations need to rubber stamp all requests the receive. The best policy is to turn over these requests to a community association attorney who is highly experienced with requests for accommodations under the fair housing laws. This way, you can ensure, to the fullest extent the law allows, that any request for an exception to your pet rules is properly investigated and documented. Some people making false claims for fair housing accommodations will back off when asked to produce proper documentation while others are more intransigent and will proceed to acquire documentation off the internet without ever seeing a medical professional. It is also important to remember that there are individuals who are truly in need of an emotional support animal and are legally entitled to a reasonable accommodation. Your job as a volunteer Board member or community association manager should be to work with your counsel to comply with the law and avoid the often significant penalties and costs associated with violating the fair housing laws while protecting the integrity of your pet restrictions.
The appeal of monetizing one’s assets should really come as no surprise as that appeal is strong and there is no asset more easily monetized than a Florida getaway. For volunteer boards attempting to deal with a member’s desire to do whatever he or she pleases with regard to occupancy of his or her unit, getting a handle on short-term rental activity and fraudulent ESA requests will certainly require the assistance of experienced counsel, a little ingenuity and a whole lot of patience.
For board members and managers in Florida who have more questions about this blog topic, you may reach me at email@example.com or by phone at 954-364-6031.